In the shadowy streets of Cleveland, Tennessee, Tall Betsy roamed—a figure woven into local folklore, a cautionary tale whispered by parents to keep their children safe. The Lady in Black, as she was known, was said to be impossibly tall, her presence evoking fear in the hearts of those who dared to linger after dark.

Dr. William Herman Schultz, a local physician, once encountered her in the early 1920s. He described her towering figure and haunting eyes, a vision that would haunt him for the rest of his days. As Halloween approached, children, emboldened by the thrill of trick-or-treating, ignored the warnings about her lurking in the shadows, waiting for the careless to stray too far from home.

Local businessman Allan Jones revived the legend in the 1980s by creating a towering goblin that embodied Tall Betsy, terrifying children and delighting adults. Her story grew darker, with poems warning that she would whisk away any child out past curfew to a mausoleum at Fort Hill Cemetery, where she would feast upon them and discard their bones.

Over the years, the line between myth and reality blurred. Flora Shields, a woman linked to the legend, was suggested as the original Tall Betsy, but the truth remained elusive. The mausoleum became a focal point for the town’s Halloween celebrations, and her legend persisted, a haunting reminder of the dangers of the night.

As the years passed, the boundary between myth and reality began to blur. The town continued to honor Tall Betsy, with events like the Halloween Block Party and the Tall Betsy 5K race. Yet, whispers of doubt surfaced about her legacy and her true nature. Was she a protector or a malevolent spirit?

In the end, as Halloween night drew near, parents would remind their children to return home before dark, urging caution with the chilling refrain: “If you see Tall Betsy, run.” For in the twilight, she remained a constant presence, a haunting figure waiting for the careless to wander too close, a reminder that some legends are best left undisturbed.

Visit the Tall Betsy Website, if you dare. https://tallbetsy.com/

JC Bowman is the Executive Director of Professional Educators of Tennessee, and the Contributing Editor of TriStar Daily.