Tennessee has discovered an intriguing approach to fixing struggling public schools: when the people running them fail to produce acceptable results, replace them with another group who promise they can do better.
What could go wrong?
The state’s attempted takeover of Memphis-Shelby County Schools and discussions of increased scrutiny of Metro Nashville Public Schools have sparked predictable political fireworks. Critics allege racial and political motives. Supporters cite academic failure, financial mismanagement, and leadership instability. Both sides might benefit from examining the evidence before reaching a verdict. In any event, facts should matter more than feelings. And student achievement should matter more than political objectives.
Memphis and Nashville operate Tennessee’s largest school districts. Their enormous budgets, complex administrations, and highly visible problems naturally attract attention. But size is not a statutory violation, nor is geography. Racial demographics alone establish neither discriminatory intent nor its absence — as long as the standards are applied fairly and consistently.
If accountability is the standard, it should apply everywhere. Under Tennessee’s 2026 school accountability law, state oversight is triggered when districts meet at least four of six statutory criteria involving academic performance, absenteeism, school ratings, financial deficiencies, and leadership instability.
Memphis was identified as the only district meeting that threshold when the legislation passed. Whether the state properly applied those criteria is now being litigated.
A federal judge cleared the way for intervention in October, but a Shelby County court subsequently blocked the takeover. On November 10, Chancellor JoeDae Jenkins continued the restriction, scheduling further arguments for December 2.
Meanwhile, the appointed oversight board continues to meet but cannot exercise takeover authority. There is something wonderfully bureaucratic about creating another layer of government to fix an existing one, only to spend months in court debating which one has the authority to govern.
Yet the legal question is serious. If Tennessee demands compliance from school districts, the state must follow its own rules.
Memphis is hardly alone in facing challenges. During legislative consideration, Tennessee Department of Education officials identified seven education systems, including Memphis, that met three of the four academic and attendance benchmarks under discussion. The others were Lewis, Jackson-Madison, Campbell, and Cocke counties, along with two state-operated systems. These were preliminary performance benchmarks, not findings that those districts met the takeover threshold under the enacted law.
Lewis County Schools reported approximately 32% proficiency in elementary and middle school mathematics and English language arts. High school Algebra I proficiency was approximately 10%. The districtwide average is affected by the virtual academy, while some traditional schools perform better. Jackson-Madison County reported roughly 26% proficiency in elementary and middle school mathematics and English. Algebra I proficiency was about 17%, though graduation outcomes and academic growth offer encouraging counterpoints.
Then consider Polk County, a predominantly white, rural district in southeast Tennessee. Polk County Schools serves about 2,000 students, yet its academic and financial problems deserve much greater attention than they have received.
In 2025–26, only 31.7% of Polk students in grades three through eight met mathematics expectations. English language arts proficiency was 35%. At Polk County High School, only 14.7% met Algebra I expectations, compared with 32.3% statewide. In that foundational English course, English I proficiency was 27.5%. Fewer than three in ten students met expectations in that foundational English course. Those numbers should alarm parents, taxpayers, and state officials alike.
Financial oversight is equally troubling. The Tennessee Comptroller’s 2025 audit identified 12 findings, seven of which repeated the previous year’s. Problems in the school department included delayed financial records, budget violations, fund deficits, inadequate internal controls, and an unresolved $250,000 revenue anticipation note.
These are not merely administrative problems. Repeated deficiencies suggest previous warnings have not led to corrective action. They have repeatedly thumbed their noses at the state. Polk has also experienced leadership turmoil, and more appears to be ahead. Yet the real question remains unanswered: Who is responsible for addressing the academic and financial weaknesses, and when will the public see measurable improvement?
Despite these failures, no verified evidence shows that the state has formally considered taking over Polk County Schools. The district’s predominantly white enrollment makes it a useful test of the claim that state scrutiny is driven primarily by race rather than data. The point is that serious educational and governance problems are not limited to Tennessee’s predominantly minority urban districts. That does not disprove allegations of selective enforcement. It demonstrates why those allegations should be examined thoroughly against consistent statewide evidence that it is not just poor minority school districts that are failing their students.
Tennessee’s experience with the Achievement School District provides another caution. Replacing local governance does not automatically improve classroom instruction. If rearranging bureaucracies guaranteed academic excellence, Washington would have solved education decades ago.
Local control matters. Elected school boards are accountable to their communities. Removing their authority requires compelling evidence, due process, and a clear path to restore local governance. But local control cannot be a permanent excuse for failure.
Tennessee should publicly identify which districts meet each statutory benchmark, require meaningful corrective plans, and explain when intervention becomes necessary. The same expectations should apply in Memphis, Nashville, Jackson, and in majority white districts like Polk County.
Academic improvement, responsible spending, and transparent leadership should matter more than political geography. If accountability applies only to certain ZIP codes, it isn’t accountability. It’s selective enforcement backed by a better public-relations department.
Steve Gill is Editor and Publisher of TriStar Daily.


