I keep thinking I’m done talking about the College Football Playoff committee.
I’d honestly become one of those guys. Just win the games. It doesn’t matter what they say. Then every Tuesday night, the rankings come out, committee chair Hunter Yurachek goes on TV, and there’s another contradiction.
Last week, Indiana dropped five spots without playing. They were off, teams they’d beaten lost, and the committee docked them for it. Five spots for a bye week is heavy. But I get it. I never had Indiana that high, because they hadn’t beaten a ranked team until USC. Fine. That’s a rule. Now apply it.
This past Saturday, Alabama beat Vanderbilt, and the other five SEC teams Alabama has beaten all lost. Kentucky. South Carolina. LSU. Mississippi State. Texas A&M. Every one of them.
But Alabama didn’t move. Not one spot.
Same situation. Opposite result. The Big Ten crowd wants to call that SEC bias. It’s not. Tennessee is in the SEC too, and look what’s happening to us. This is Alabama bias. Brand-name bias. Calling it SEC bias is lazy, and it lets the committee off the hook.
Yurachek’s explanation made it worse. Alabama won at Vanderbilt by 15 with an offense that didn’t play their best, and he gave them credit for avoiding a letdown.
Tennessee got stuck in Knoxville for five hours, landed in College Station around midnight, trailed at halftime and won at Texas A&M by 15. Same margin, but not the same win. Alabama was favored by more than two touchdowns and didn’t cover. Tennessee covered by almost two touchdowns.
Alabama stayed at No. 3. We dropped one spot, from No. 8 to No. 9. According to Yurachek, part of the reason is that the committee sees Tennessee as a defense-first team with the 38th-ranked offense in the country in relative scoring.
Look at how they treat defense. Tennessee held Texas A&M to eight first downs and 179 yards, on the road. USC put up 409 yards on Indiana, in Bloomington. Indiana jumped us anyway, and Yurachek said what really impressed the committee was Indiana’s offense. When Tennessee plays great defense, the committee talks about our offense. When Indiana gives up 409 yards, the committee talks about their offense.
Football is half offense and half defense. But listen to Yurachek on a Tuesday night. Relative scoring offense. Almost 450 yards. A steady, consistent offense. When he does bring up defense, it’s to say a team leans on it too much. This committee doesn’t know what to do with a team that wins with defense. That’s funny, because that’s exactly how Nick Saban built the Alabama dynasty.
And then came the best part. Yurachek bragged that Alabama has won their six conference games by an average of almost 23 points.
Six. Alabama has played eight SEC games.
He left out the two they lost. One of them was by 16, at Neyland, to the Tennessee team he’d just ranked six spots behind them. The chairman of the committee went on national TV and counted only the games Alabama won.
These self-proclaimed geniuses love to get cute. Strength of record. Letdown spots. Pools, or pods, or whatever they’re calling it this week. They get so far into the weeds they miss what’s sitting right in front of them.
How can you not compare these two teams? Same conference. Same 8-2 record. They played each other, and Tennessee won by 16. Tennessee’s two losses came by a combined six points. Alabama’s came by 19. They already have three common opponents, and when Tennessee plays LSU and Vanderbilt, it’ll be five. If those two teams aren’t comparable, I don’t know what the word means.
Three weeks in a row, the committee has found a reason not to compare them anyway. First they just never did. Then the two teams were in different pods. Now it’s our offense.
It’s daddy ball with a television contract. I don’t think you can even take them seriously anymore.
Here’s what I think is really going on. The committee has been kicking the can down the road, hoping Tennessee loses so they never have to make the call.
First it was Kentucky, ranked sixth by the committee at the time. Tennessee won by 28. Then it was a road trip to Texas A&M. Tennessee won by 15. Now LSU is favored at Neyland, and if Tennessee wins that one, it’ll be, well, Vanderbilt on the road can be tough.
After Vanderbilt, they run out of road. The final rankings come out Dec. 6, and there’s no next week to wait for.
And this isn’t just about pride. Right now, the bracket sends Tennessee to Indiana for a first-round game while Alabama sits at home with a bye.
So keep winning. That’s the best way to embarrass this committee, and it looks worse for them every week. Beat LSU. Beat Vanderbilt. Get to 10-2, and make them put Tennessee and Alabama on that board side by side. Then let Hunter Yurachek go on TV and explain why the team that won by 16 belongs behind the team that lost by 16.
And that’s why I’m not done talking about it. Going quiet gives them a hall pass. They haven’t earned one.
Agree? Like it and follow. Disagree? Let me hear it in the comments.
Jeremy Durham is a sports columnist for TriStar Daily and the founder of Five and a Fade.


